Established
Light Station
State
Status of Original Lighthouse Status of Light Station
1716
Boston (Little Brewster Island)
MA
destroyed in 1776 by during the American Revolution active - current tower built in 1783
1746
Brant Point (Nantucket)
MA
destroyed by fire in 1758

active - current tower built 1901
7 lighthouses and 3 other lighted beacons have stood at this location.

1749
Beavertail (Narragansett Bay)
RI
first tower (wooden) destroyed by fire in 1753
second tower (brick & stone) built 1754
second tower demolished & replaced 1856
active - current tower built 1856
1760
New London Harbor
CT
demolished and replaced with a new tower in 1801 active - current tower built 1801
1764
Sandy Hook
NJ
only surviving colonial era lighthouse active
1767
Cape Henlopen
DE
deactivated 1924; collapsed 1926 due to erosion discontinued (destroyed lighthouse not replaced)
1768
Charleston (Morris Island)
SC
destroyed in 1861 during the American Civil War inactive - current tower built in 1876
station discontinued in 1962 due to erosion
1768
Plymouth Twin Lights (Gurnet Point)
MA
destroyed by fire ca. 1800 active - oldest wooden lighthouse in the US
twin lights rebuilt 1801 & 1843; one tower removed ca. 1920
1771
Portsmouth Harbor
NH
replaced in 1804 active - current built in 1878
1771
Cape Ann (Thatcher Island)
MA
replaced in 1861 active - current twin towers built in 1861
North light discontinued 1932; reactivated as private aid to navigation in 1980s.
1773?*
Tybee Island
GA
successor to two unlighted day beacons (1736 & 1742)
destroyed in 1862 during the American Civil War
active - current tower built in 1867

* There is some debate whether the third tower at Tybee Island was lighted from the beginning

Sources:
Lighthousefriends.com
Kevin Duffee. "A Tale Of Two Carolina Lighthouses: A Longstanding Puzzle Solved?" Keeper's Log. Spring 2020. 16-22.
George Worthylake. "Cape Henlopen." Keeper's Log. Winter 1992.